A modest record — below the level that usually signals systemic problems. More recorded distress than 74% of 6-24-unit residential buildings citywide. The citywide median for 6-24-unit residential buildings is 16.3 penalty
points per 10 units; this building carries 55.8. In ZIP 10003, 67% of residential buildings hold an A and
4% grade D or F.
How grades work
this building
A
B
C
Among 46,798 6-24-unit residential buildings citywide · left is less recorded distress, right is more
Open with the city right now
Open HPD violations
3 total — 1 class C (immediately hazardous), 2 class B, 0 class A. Oldest open since 2024-10-16.
status snapshot refreshed weekly from HPD records
Patterns
8 heat or hot-water complaints in the last three years (winter 2024–25: 2 · winter 2025–26: 6). Repeated winter clusters suggest a chronic heating problem.
2
’24–25
6
’25–26
No bedbug-infested units reported in the last three years of filings.
What 311 hears from this address
16 service requests in the last three years. Most common: HEAT/HOT WATER (4) · Lead (2) · Encampment (2) · Boilers (1) · Illegal Parking (1) · For Hire Vehicle Complaint (1).
Filed construction activity
$176,000 in permitted construction work filed since
2016 (5 filings with a declared cost) — a rough measure of how actively
the owner maintains the building. Permit costs cover filed construction work only — they do not
capture routine maintenance or repairs done without a permit.
Rent-stabilization signals
Yes
Built before 1974 (1854)
Yes
Six or more residential units (11)
No
421-a / J-51 tax benefit on the current tax roll
2 of 3 signals present. This is the classic profile of a rent-stabilized building (pre-1974, 6+ units) — many units in such buildings remain stabilized. The definitive answer for any unit:
request its rent history from NYS Homes & Community Renewal (free, at hcr.ny.gov).
Registered with HPD — the names behind the building
Registered owner(s)
129 LLC
Head officer
NORMAN LIVINGSTON
Managing agent
TRI-HILL MANAGEMENT LLC
Last registered
2025-11-21
as filed by the owner in the building's HPD registration
What the city thinks it's worth
Tax year
City market value
Assessed value
2025
$2,347,000
$1,056,150
2026
$2,618,000
$1,178,100
2027
$2,932,000
$1,319,400
The city's market estimate has risen
25% between tax years 2025 and 2027.
Building systems
Heating fuel
NO2FUEL
Flood exposure
Not in the FEMA 1%-annual-chance floodplain (2015 preliminary maps).
Not in a hurricane evacuation zone.
Not in the city's stormwater (cloudburst) flood maps under any modeled scenario.
No street-flooding or sewer-backup complaints on record at this address.
Sources: FEMA flood maps (coastal), NYC DEP Stormwater Flood Maps
(cloudburst), NYC hurricane evacuation zones, and 311 records for this address.
Getting around
Subway
Astor Pl — 6 · 900 ft straight-line (about a 4-minute walk) · station accessibility: none 3 Av — L · 1,000 ft straight-line (about a 5-minute walk) · station accessibility: none
Bus
Nearest boarding stop: E 9 St / 2 Av — M8 · 350 ft
Citi Bike
E 10 St & 2 Ave · 350 ft · station location as of 2026-09-23; live availability
School zones (2024–25 map)
Elementary: Elementary schools in this district are not zoned. Confirm with the DOE's school search.
Distances are straight-line, not walking routes. Transit locations from the MTA and
Citi Bike, bike facilities from NYC DOT, school zones from the DOE's 2024–25 maps.
16 311 service requests from this address in the last three years — 4 of them about heat or hot water.
311 will ask for the address, the apartment if the problem is inside, and what's wrong.
Contact details are optional for most complaints; food-poisoning reports can be anonymous. Complaints
appear in the city's public 311 data, usually within a day or two, and then in the Live from 311 box
on this page.
Tenant complaint: HEAT/HOT WATER — ENTIRE BUILDING
2025-12-02
Bedbug filing: 0 infested units
2025-11-17
HPD class I: §27-2107 ADM CODE OWNER FAILED TO FILE A VALID REGISTRATION STATEMENT WITH THE DEPARTMENT AS REQUIRED BY ADM CODE §27-2097 AND IS THEREFORE
2025-11-06
Rodent inspection: Passed
The full timeline
2026
2026-10-07311: Curb Condition — Broken Curb
2026-09-17311: Encampment — N/A
2026-09-17311: Encampment — N/A
2026-09-15Rodent inspection: Passed
2026-06-26Rodent inspection: Bait applied
2026-05-28Rodent inspection: Failed for Rat Activity
2026-04-16Rodent inspection: Failed for Rat Activity
2026-02-21311: Noise — Noise: Jack Hammering (NC2)
2026-02-11311: Lead — Lead Kit Request (Residential) (L10)
2025
2025-12-31311: HEAT/HOT WATER — APARTMENT ONLY
2025-12-31311: HEAT/HOT WATER — ENTIRE BUILDING
2025-12-31311: HEAT/HOT WATER — APARTMENT ONLY
2025-12-31Tenant complaint: HEAT/HOT WATER — APARTMENT ONLY
2025-12-31Tenant complaint: HEAT/HOT WATER — APARTMENT ONLY
2025-12-31Tenant complaint: HEAT/HOT WATER — ENTIRE BUILDING
2025-12-02Bedbug filing: 0 infested units
2025-11-17HPD class I: §27-2107 ADM CODE OWNER FAILED TO FILE A VALID REGISTRATION STATEMENT WITH THE DEPARTMENT AS REQUIRED BY ADM CODE §27-2097 AND IS THEREFORE
2025-11-06Rodent inspection: Passed
2025-10-08Rodent inspection: Failed for Rat Activity and Other Reason
2025-10-01311: Panhandling — N/A
2025-09-29Boiler inspection
2025-09-29Boiler inspection — defects found
2025-08-31311: Dead Animal — Rat or Mouse
2025-07-22311: PLUMBING — TOILET
2025-07-22Tenant complaint: PLUMBING — TOILET
2025-04-09Rodent inspection: Passed
2025-03-25311: For Hire Vehicle Complaint — Driver Complaint - Non Passenger
2025-02-07Bedbug filing: 0 infested units
2025-01-03311: Lead — Lead Kit Request (Residential) (L10)
2024
2024-12-30Boiler inspection
2024-12-30Boiler inspection
2024-11-25Rodent inspection: Failed for Rat Activity
2024-11-22HPD class I: §27-2107 ADM CODE OWNER FAILED TO FILE A VALID REGISTRATION STATEMENT WITH THE DEPARTMENT AS REQUIRED BY ADM CODE §27-2097 AND IS THEREFORE
2024-10-18311: Illegal Parking — Blocked Bike Lane
2024-10-16HPD class B: § 27-2046.1 HMC: REPAIR OR REPLACE THE CARBON MONOXIDE DETECTING DEVICE(S). MISSING IN THE ENTIRE APARTMENT LOCATED AT APT 5, 4th STORY, 1st
2024-10-16HPD class B: § 27-2045 ADM CODE REPAIR OR REPLACE THE SMOKE DETECTOR MISSING IN THE ENTIRE APARTMENT LOCATED AT APT 5, 4th STORY, 1st APARTMENT FROM EAST
2024-10-16HPD class C: § 27-2005, 2007 ADM CODE REMOVE DEVICE PREVENTING DOOR FROM BEING SELF-CLOSING KICK STAND AT BUILDING ENTRANCE DOOR AT PUBLIC HALL, 1st STOR
2024-10-16HPD class C: § 27-2005, 2007 ADM CODE REMOVE DEVICE PREVENTING DOOR FROM BEING SELF-CLOSING KICK STAND AT VESTIBULE DOOR AT PUBLIC HALL, 1st STORY
2024-10-16HPD class C: § 27-2005 ADM CODE & 309 M/D LAW ABATE THE NUISANCE CONSISTING OF HOT WATER EXCEEDING 130 DEGREES AT ALL HOT WATER FIXTURES IN THE ENTIRE AP
2024-10-14311: HEAT/HOT WATER — APARTMENT ONLY
2024-10-14Tenant complaint: HEAT/HOT WATER — APARTMENT ONLY
2024-10-09Rodent inspection: Failed for Rat Activity
2024-06-07Job filed: Propose interior renovation at partial 5th floor (apartment 10) of existing residential building with partition work and finish work as per plan. No c$27,000
2024-04-15Permit Plumbing — Signed-off
2024-04-10Permit General Construction — Signed-off
2024-04-04Rodent inspection: Failed for Rat Activity
2024-04-03Job filed: Propose plumbing work at partial 5th floor (apartment 10) of existing residential building as per plan. No change in use, egress, or occupancy.$2,000
2024-04-03Job filed: Propose interior renovation at partial 5th floor (apartment 10) of existing residential building with partition work and finish work as per plan. No c$27,000
2024-03-27Rodent inspection: Bait applied
2024-03-20Rodent inspection: Bait applied
2024-03-13Rodent inspection: Bait applied
2024-02-27Rodent inspection: Failed for Rat Activity
2024-01-04Rodent inspection: Bait applied
2023
2023-12-21Rodent inspection: Bait applied
2023-12-20Bedbug filing: 0 infested units
2023-12-07Rodent inspection: Bait applied
2023-11-21Rodent inspection: Failed for Rat Activity
2023-10-12Rodent inspection: Failed for Rat Activity
2023-04-25311: Abandoned Bike — Chained to Public Property
2023-04-17Rodent inspection: Stoppage done
2023-04-06Rodent inspection: Failed for Rat Activity
2023-03-17Bedbug filing: 0 infested units
2023-03-15HPD class A: (A) § HMC:FILE ANNUAL BEDBUG REPORT IN ACCORDANCE WITH HPD RULE AS DESCRIBED ON THE BACK OF THIS NOTICE OF VIOLATION OR AS DESCRIBED ON HPD
2022
2022-11-01Rodent inspection: Failed for Rat Activity and Other Reason
2022-10-11Rodent inspection: Failed for Rat Activity
2022-09-20Bedbug filing: 0 infested units
2022-06-20Boiler inspection
2022-06-20Boiler inspection
2022-04-06Rodent inspection: Passed
2022-02-15HPD class A: (A) § HMC:FILE ANNUAL BEDBUG REPORT IN ACCORDANCE WITH HPD RULE AS DESCRIBED ON THE BACK OF THIS NOTICE OF VIOLATION OR AS DESCRIBED ON HPD
2022-02-15HPD class I: §27-2107 ADM CODE OWNER FAILED TO FILE A VALID REGISTRATION STATEMENT WITH THE DEPARTMENT AS REQUIRED BY ADM CODE §27-2097 AND IS THEREFORE
2021
2021-11-29311: Request Large Bulky Item Collection — Request Large Bulky Item Collection
2021-10-28Boiler inspection
2021-10-28Boiler inspection
2021-05-21Bedbug filing: 0 infested units
2021-04-27Rodent inspection: Passed
2021-04-01HPD class A: (A) § HMC:FILE ANNUAL BEDBUG REPORT IN ACCORDANCE WITH HPD RULE AS DESCRIBED ON THE BACK OF THIS NOTICE OF VIOLATION OR AS DESCRIBED ON HPD
2020
2020-11-02311: Noise - Residential — Loud Talking
2020-07-21Rodent inspection: Failed for Rat Activity
2020-05-20Rodent inspection: Failed for Rat Activity
2020-04-15Boiler inspection
2020-04-15Boiler inspection
2020-02-19311: Sanitation Condition — 15 Street Cond/Dump-Out/Drop-Off
2019
2019-12-12311: Request Large Bulky Item Collection — Request Large Bulky Item Collection
2019-11-13Rodent inspection: Passed
2019-10-01Rodent inspection: Failed for Rat Activity
2019-09-09311: Air Quality — Air: Odor/Fumes, Vehicle Idling (AD3)
2019-07-31Boiler inspection
2019-07-31Boiler inspection
2019-05-02311: Street Condition — Defective Hardware
2019-05-02311: Street Condition — Defective Hardware
2017-10-19Rodent inspection: Failed for Rat Activity
2017-10-18Boiler inspection
2017-10-18Boiler inspection
2017-09-01Rodent inspection: Passed
2017-05-08311: Street Condition — Defective Hardware
2017-03-02Certificate of occupancy Final
2016
2016-12-13311: Street Condition — Defective Hardware
2016-12-05Rodent inspection: Passed
2016-10-27311: Street Condition — Defective Hardware
2016-10-24HPD class I: §27-2107 ADM CODE OWNER FAILED TO FILE A VALID REGISTRATION STATEMENT WITH THE DEPARTMENT AS REQUIRED BY ADM CODE §27-2097 AND IS THEREFORE
2016-05-17311: Street Condition — Defective Hardware
2016-05-11311: Street Condition — Defective Hardware
2016-05-04311: Street Condition — Defective Hardware
2016-04-27Permit AL — ISSUED
2016-04-25311: Street Condition — Defective Hardware
2016-04-20311: Street Condition — Defective Hardware
2016-04-14Rodent inspection: Failed for Rat Activity
2016-04-14311: Street Condition — Defective Hardware
2016-03-08311: Street Condition — Defective Hardware
2016-01-29Job filed: GENERAL CONSTRUCTION AT 3RD AND 4TH FLOORS AND MECHANICAL WORK FOR AC UNIT AT ROOF INDICATED ON DRAWINGS FILED HEREWITH AND OBTAIN A NEW CERTIFICATE O$60,000
2016-01-29Job filed: GENERAL CONSTRUCTION AT 3RD AND 4TH FLOORS AND MECHANICAL WORK FOR AC UNIT AT ROOF INDICATED ON DRAWINGS FILED HEREWITH AND OBTAIN A NEW CERTIFICATE O$60,000
2016-01-12Rodent inspection: Failed for Rat Activity
2016-01-06311: Water System — Leak (Use Comments) (WA2)
2015
2015-12-22Permit PL — ISSUED
2015-12-22Permit EW — ISSUED
2015-08-22311: Homeless Person Assistance — Status Call
2015-07-18311: Homeless Person Assistance — Status Call
2015-07-17311: Homeless Person Assistance — Status Call
2015-07-09311: Homeless Encampment — N/A
2015-07-08311: Homeless Person Assistance — Status Call
2015-05-20Permit EW — ISSUED
2015-05-20Permit EW — ISSUED
2015-05-01Permit EQ — ISSUED
2015-04-28Job filed: INSTALLATION OF PIPE SCAFFOLD AS PER PLANS. WORK SHALL COMPLY WITH 2014 BUILDING CODE CHAPTER 33. NO CHANGE IN USE EGRESS OR OCCUPANCY.
2015-04-07Rodent inspection: Passed
2014
2014-03-25Rodent inspection: Passed
2013
2013-09-11311: Street Condition — Defective Hardware
2013-08-22Job filed: GENERAL CONSTRUCTION AT 3RD AND 4TH FLOORS AND MECHANICAL WORK FOR AC UNIT AT OSP INDICATED ON DRAWING FILED HEREWITH. OBTAIN A NEW CERTIFICATE OF OCC$60,000
2013-06-03Rodent inspection: Bait applied
2013-05-30311: Street Condition — Defective Hardware
2013-05-09Rodent inspection: Bait applied
2013-04-18Rodent inspection: Bait applied
2013-04-11Rodent inspection: Failed for Rat Activity
2013-03-18Rodent inspection: Failed for Rat Activity
2013-01-09Permit EW — ISSUED
2013-01-09Permit PL — ISSUED
2013-01-09Job filed: INSTALL GAS HOT WATER BOILER PER PLANS.$15,000
2013-01-09Job filed: INSTALL GAS HOT WATER BOILER PER PLANS.$15,000
2013-01-09Job filed: INSTALL GAS HOT WATER BOILER PER PLANS.$15,000
2012
2012-09-18Permit PL — ISSUED
2012-08-06Permit EW — ISSUED
2012-07-06Job filed: GENERAL CONSTRUCTION AND PLUMBING WORK INDICATED ON DRAWINGS FILED HEREWITH. NO CHANGE IN USE EGRESS OR OCCUPANCY UNDER THIS APPLICATION.$21,000
2012-07-06Job filed: GENERAL CONSTRUCTION AND PLUMBING WORK INDICATED ON DRAWINGS FILED HEREWITH. NO CHANGE IN USE EGRESS OR OCCUPANCY UNDER THIS APPLICATION.$21,000
2012-05-12Rodent inspection: Passed
2012-04-16DOB complaint, category ?
2012-03-20RPTT&RET — from ESTATE OF PHYLLIS WINSTRAL MILLER; JONATHAN MILLER, EXECUTOR to JONATHAN MILLER, TRUSTEE; CARY ANTILL, TRUSTEE; CREDIT SHELTER TRUST NO. 1
2012-02-17ECB CLASS - 1 violation: FAILURE TO SAFEGUARD ALL PERSONS AND PROPERTY AFFECTED BY CONSTRUCTIONOPERATIONS. DEFECTS NOTED: AT TIME OF INSPECTION FIRE RATING
2010-04-13Job filed: COMBINE APTS AT BASEMENT, 1ST AND 2ND FLOORS GENERAL CONSTRUCTION, MECHANICAL, STRUCTURAL AND PLUMBING WORK INDICATED ON DRAWINGS FILED HEREWITH. NO C$476,000
2010-04-12Rodent inspection: Passed
2009
2009-05-01Permit PL — ISSUED
2009-04-22Permit EW — ISSUED
2009-04-22Permit EW — ISSUED
2009-03-12Job filed: COMBINE 2 APARTMENTS AT THE 4TH FLOOR GENERAL CONSTRUCTION MECHANICAL VENT AND PLUMBING WORK INDICATED ON DRAWINGS FILED HEREWITH NO CHANGE IN USE EGR$56,000
2009-03-12Job filed: COMBINE 2 APARTMENTS AT THE 4TH FLOOR GENERAL CONSTRUCTION MECHANICAL VENT AND PLUMBING WORK INDICATED ON DRAWINGS FILED HEREWITH NO CHANGE IN USE EGR$56,000
2004
2004-03-23Deed — from WINSTRAL-MILLER, PHYLLIS; MILLER, JONATHAN to 129 LLC
1991
1991-01-28Deed — from MILLER, JONATHAN to MILLER, JONATHAN; WINSTRAL-MILLER, PHYLLIS
1989
1989-12-18Mortgage satisfied — from MERDEKA RLTY CORP to AMALGATED BANK N.Y.
1986
1986-08-05Agreement — from MILLER, JONATHAN to STATEN ISLAND SVGS BK
1984
1984-05-04Agreement — from MILLER, JONATHAN to STATEN ISLAND SAVGSBANK
1982
1982-07-08Agreement — from MILLER, JONATHAN to STATEN ISLAND SAV'SBK
1977
1977-07-13Deed — from MILLER, JONATHAN to MERDEKA REALTY CORP
1977-07-13Mortgage assigned — from AMALGAMATED BANK OFN Y to STATEN ISLAND SVGS BANK
1977-07-13Agreement — from MERDEKA REALTY CORP to STATEN ISLAND SVGS BANK
1977-07-13Deed — from MERDEKA REALTY CORP to MILLER, JONATHAN
1975
1975-05-09SAGE — from MILLER, JONATHAN; BALLANTINE, LESLIE FROST
1973
1973-12-26PSAT — from PROTESTANT EPSCPAL ETAL
1973-12-21Mortgage — from MERDEKA REALTY CORP to AMALGAMATED BANK OFN Y
1973-12-21Deed — from MILLER, JONATHAN to MERDEKA REALTY CORP
1973-12-21Deed — from MERDEKA REALTY CORP to MILLER, JONATHAN
1970
1970-07-02Mortgage — from MILLER, JONATHAN to LEWIN, MICHAEL; LAMBERT, MARGOT; STEVENS, PETER; HENLEY, ERNEST J; MILLER, IRVING; STRUNSK
1970-07-02Agreement — from MILLER, JONATHAN S to RECTOR CHURCH WRDNSETAL
1970-07-02SAGE — from RECTOR CHURCH WRDNSETAL
1970-07-02Deed — from MILLER, JONATHAN to BALLANTINE, LESLEY F
1970-07-02Mortgage — from BALLNATINE, LESLEY F to MILLER, JONATHAN
1969
1969-04-28Deed — from STRAW MAN INC to MILLER, JONATHAN
1969-04-18Mortgage — from GHEE, PETER H; GHEE, GRETA C to SECOND AVE HOLDING CORP
1969-04-18Deed — from RECTOR CHURCH WRDRSETAL to STRAW MAN INC
1969-04-18Mortgage — from STRAW MAN INC to RECTOR CHURCH WRDNSETAL
1969-04-18SAGE — from STRAWMAN INC; OPPENHEIMER, JOAN A; GHEE, GRETA; GHEE, PETER H
1969-04-18Deed — from RECTOR CHURCH WRDRSETAL to SECOND AVE HOLDING CORP
1969-04-18Mortgage — from SECOND AVE HOLDING CORP to RECTOR CHURCH WRDNSETAL
1969-04-18Mortgage assigned — from SECOND AVE HOLDING CORP to STEVENS, PETER; LAMBERT, MARGOT; LEWIN, MICHAEL; LEWIN, JOAN; HENLEY, ERNEST J; STRUNSKY,
1969-04-18Deed — from RECTOR CHRUCH WRDNSETAL to SECOND AVE HOLDING CORP
1969-04-18Mortgage — from SECOND AVE HOLDING CORP to RECTOR CHURCH WRDNSETAL
1969-04-18Deed — from SECOND AVE HOLDING CORP to OPPENHEIMER, JOAN A
1969-04-18Mortgage — from OPPENHEIMER, JOAN A to SECOND AVE HOLDING CORP
1969-04-18SAGE — from OPPENHEIMER, JOAN A; GHEE, GRETA; GHEE, PETER H
1969-04-18Deed — from RECTOR CHURCH WRDRSETAL to STRAW MAN INC
1969-04-18Deed — from SECOND AVE HOLDING CORP to GHEE, GRETA C; GHEE, PETER H
1969-01-21MISC — from LANDMARK PRESERVATNCOMM
1900
1900-01-01Air permit (CERTIFICATE TO OPERATE), fuel: NO4FUEL