The city's published records show little recorded distress here in the last three years. More recorded distress than 56% of 6-24-unit residential buildings citywide. The citywide median for 6-24-unit residential buildings is 16.3 penalty
points per 10 units; this building carries 20.8. In ZIP 10019, 65% of residential buildings hold an A and
4% grade D or F.
How grades work
this building
A
B
C
Among 46,798 6-24-unit residential buildings citywide · left is less recorded distress, right is more
Open with the city right now
No current HPD flags in the latest weekly snapshot: no open violations, no
pending litigation, no active vacate orders, and not in the Alternative Enforcement Program.
Patterns
8 heat or hot-water complaints in the last three years (winter 2024–25: 6 · winter 2025–26: 2). Repeated winter clusters suggest a chronic heating problem.
6
’24–25
2
’25–26
No bedbug-infested units reported in the last three years of filings.
$2,400 in enforcement penalties imposed (ECB/OATH) in the last three years.
What 311 hears from this address
14 service requests in the last three years. Most common: HEAT/HOT WATER (4) · Noise (2) · Lead (1) · GENERAL (1) · Real Time Enforcement (1) · Homeless Person Assistance (1).
Filed construction activity
$9,000 in permitted construction work filed since
2016 (1 filings with a declared cost) — a rough measure of how actively
the owner maintains the building. Permit costs cover filed construction work only — they do not
capture routine maintenance or repairs done without a permit.
Rent-stabilization signals
Yes
Built before 1974 (1910)
Yes
Six or more residential units (15)
No
421-a / J-51 tax benefit on the current tax roll
2 of 3 signals present. This is the classic profile of a rent-stabilized building (pre-1974, 6+ units) — many units in such buildings remain stabilized. The definitive answer for any unit:
request its rent history from NYS Homes & Community Renewal (free, at hcr.ny.gov).
Registered with HPD — the names behind the building
Registered owner(s)
458 WEST 57 STREET, HDFC
Head officer
NORMA DUNKELBERGER
Managing agent
HSC MANAGEMENT CORP
Last registered
2025-07-01
as filed by the owner in the building's HPD registration
What the city thinks it's worth
Tax year
City market value
Assessed value
2025
$1,467,000
$660,150
2026
$1,560,000
$702,000
2027
$1,682,000
$756,900
The city's market estimate has risen
15% between tax years 2025 and 2027.
For property tax, the Department of Finance values this co-op
as if it were a rental building. Its 2021 estimate: gross income $321,483 a year
($31.83 per sq ft), operating expenses $154,328
($15.28 per sq ft), net operating income $167,155. These are the
city's estimates from comparable rentals, not the building's actual budget, rents or maintenance
charges.
Building systems
Heating fuel
NATURALGAS
Flood exposure
Not in the FEMA 1%-annual-chance floodplain (2015 preliminary maps).
Not in a hurricane evacuation zone.
Not in the city's stormwater (cloudburst) flood maps under any modeled scenario.
No street-flooding or sewer-backup complaints on record at this address.
Sources: FEMA flood maps (coastal), NYC DEP Stormwater Flood Maps
(cloudburst), NYC hurricane evacuation zones, and 311 records for this address.
Getting around
Subway
59 St-Columbus Circle — 1 A B C D · 0.3 mi straight-line (about an 8-minute walk) · station accessibility: full
Bus
Nearest boarding stop: 10 Av / W 57 St — M11 · 50 ft
Citi Bike
W 56 St & 10 Ave · 200 ft · station location as of 2026-09-23; live availability
Distances are straight-line, not walking routes. Transit locations from the MTA and
Citi Bike, bike facilities from NYC DOT, school zones from the DOE's 2024–25 maps.
14 311 service requests from this address in the last three years — 4 of them about heat or hot water.
311 will ask for the address, the apartment if the problem is inside, and what's wrong.
Contact details are optional for most complaints; food-poisoning reports can be anonymous. Complaints
appear in the city's public 311 data, usually within a day or two, and then in the Live from 311 box
on this page.
Most recent mortgage recorded against this lot: $110,000 on
2025-01-30 (lender: Housing Conservative Coordinators, INC.). Face amount at recording — it may have since been paid
down, refinanced or satisfied. View the recorded
document.
Date
Record
Amount
Per res. unit
2026-04-13
RPTT&RET $208,860 — from 458 WET 57TH STREET HOOUSING DEVELOPMENT to ARMSTRONG, THOMAS JAMES
$208,860
2026-03-31
Sold for $208,860
$208,860
$13,924
2025-01-30
Mortgage $110,000 — from 458 WEST 57 STREET HOUSING DEVELOPMENT F to HOUSING CONSERVATIVE COORDINATORS, INC.
$110,000
2025-01-30
AL&R $110,000 — from 458 WEST 57 STREET HOUSING DEVELOPMENT F to HOUSING CONSERVATIVE COORDINATORS, INC.
$110,000
2023-07-26
RPTT&RET $60,251 — from ESTATE OF ROBERT PAUL KALIN; ESTATE OF ROBERT P KALIN; THOMAS KALIN, ADMINISTRATOR to 458 WEST 57 STREET HOUSING DEVELOPMENT F
$60,251
2023-07-26
RPTT&RET $60,251 — from ESTATE OF ROBERT PAUL KALIN; ESTATE OF ROBERT P KALIN; THOMAS KALIN, ADMINISTRATOR to 458 WEST 57 STREET HOUSING DEVELOPMENT F
$60,251
2023-07-13
Sold for $60,251
$60,251
$4,017
2009-10-09
Mortgage $50,000 — from 456 WEST 57TH STREET HDFC to HOUSING CONSERVATION COORDINATORS, INC.
$50,000
1991-04-19
Mortgage $3,750 — from 458 WEST 57TH ST HDFC to CITY OF NEW YORK
$3,750
Ten-year activity
50250
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
2023
2024
23
2025
2026
ConstructionEnforcementHousing & tenantsOwnership & moneyHealth & systems
Show as table
Year
Construction
Enforcement
Housing & tenants
Ownership & money
Health & systems
Total
2017
0
0
3
2
2
7
2018
0
1
7
2
2
12
2019
0
0
4
3
2
9
2020
0
0
1
0
1
2
2021
0
0
0
0
2
2
2022
2
0
10
0
1
13
2023
1
0
5
3
1
10
2024
1
0
1
0
2
4
2025
1
2
16
3
1
23
2026
1
3
9
2
4
19
This record is free. Keeping it free costs money. Servers, data pipelines, weekends. Pay what you want — a dollar helps.
RPTT&RET $208,860 — from 458 WET 57TH STREET HOOUSING DEVELOPMENT to ARMSTRONG, THOMAS JAMES
2026-04-08
Rodent inspection: Passed
2026-03-31
Sold for $208,860
2026-03-12
Rodent inspection: Failed for Rat Activity
2026-02-21
311: HEAT/HOT WATER — ENTIRE BUILDING
2026-02-21
Tenant complaint: HEAT/HOT WATER — ENTIRE BUILDING
2026-02-13
DOB complaint, category ?
2026-02-06
DOB violation C: FAILURE TO MAINTAIN BUILDING IN CODE COMPLIANT MANNER. OBSERVED HAZARDOUS CONDITIONS AT EXPOSURE 1 NORTH ELEVATION. LOOSE BR
2026-02-06
ECB CLASS - 2 violation: PEDESTRIAN PROTECTION DUES NOT MEET CODE SPECIFICATION.OBSERVED DEFECTED/PARAPET PANEL DAMAGED AND LOOSE AT EXPOSURE 1.REM:COMPLY
2026-01-14
Permit Sidewalk Shed — Permit Issued
2026-01-08
311: Noise - Street/Sidewalk — Loud Music/Party
2026-01-02
Bedbug filing: 0 infested units
2025-12-04
311: Disorderly Youth — Playing in Unsuitable Place
2026-04-13RPTT&RET $208,860 — from 458 WET 57TH STREET HOOUSING DEVELOPMENT to ARMSTRONG, THOMAS JAMES$208,860
2026-04-08Rodent inspection: Passed
2026-03-31Sold for $208,860$208,860
2026-03-12Rodent inspection: Failed for Rat Activity
2026-02-21311: HEAT/HOT WATER — ENTIRE BUILDING
2026-02-21Tenant complaint: HEAT/HOT WATER — ENTIRE BUILDING
2026-02-13DOB complaint, category ?
2026-02-06DOB violation C: FAILURE TO MAINTAIN BUILDING IN CODE COMPLIANT MANNER. OBSERVED HAZARDOUS CONDITIONS AT EXPOSURE 1 NORTH ELEVATION. LOOSE BR
2026-02-06ECB CLASS - 2 violation: PEDESTRIAN PROTECTION DUES NOT MEET CODE SPECIFICATION.OBSERVED DEFECTED/PARAPET PANEL DAMAGED AND LOOSE AT EXPOSURE 1.REM:COMPLY $2,400
2025-12-04311: Disorderly Youth — Playing in Unsuitable Place
2025-10-10311: General Construction/Plumbing — Sidewalk Shed/Pipe Scafford - Inadequate Defective/None
2025-10-10DOB complaint, category ?
2025-09-02Boiler inspection
2025-07-09311: Homeless Person Assistance — Non-Chronic
2025-05-29311: Real Time Enforcement — Work Without A Permit - Occupied Multiple Dwelling
2025-05-29DOB complaint, category ?
2025-04-18311: GENERAL — COOKING GAS
2025-04-18311: HEAT/HOT WATER — ENTIRE BUILDING
2025-04-18Tenant complaint: GENERAL — COOKING GAS
2025-04-18Tenant complaint: HEAT/HOT WATER — ENTIRE BUILDING
2025-04-07311: HEAT/HOT WATER — ENTIRE BUILDING
2025-04-07Tenant complaint: HEAT/HOT WATER — ENTIRE BUILDING
2025-03-30HPD class C: § 27-2031 ADM CODE PROVIDE HOT WATER AT ALL HOT WATER FIXTURES IN THE ENTIRE APARTMENT LOCATED AT APT 1FE, 1st STORY, 1st APARTMENT FROM NOR
2025-03-30HPD class B: § 27-2005 ADM CODE PROPERLY REPAIR WITH SIMILAR MATERIAL THE BROKEN OR DEFECTIVE FIRE RETARDED MATERIAL AT EAST,WEST,SOUTH AND NORTH WALLS.
2025-03-30HPD class A: § 27-2013 ADM CODE PAINT WITH LIGHT COLORED PAINT TO THE SATISFACTION OF THIS DEPARTMENT AT EAST,WEST,SOUTH, AND NORTH WALLS. AT PUBLIC HALL
2025-03-30HPD class C: § 27-2070 ADM CODE PROVIDE AN ADEQUATE SUPPLY OF GAS TO THE FIXTURES AT RANGE IN THE KITCHEN LOCATED AT APT 1FE, 1st STORY, 1st APARTMENT FR
2025-03-28311: HEAT/HOT WATER — ENTIRE BUILDING
2025-03-28Tenant complaint: HEAT/HOT WATER — ENTIRE BUILDING
2025-01-30Mortgage $110,000 — from 458 WEST 57 STREET HOUSING DEVELOPMENT F to HOUSING CONSERVATIVE COORDINATORS, INC.$110,000
2025-01-30Mortgage satisfied — from 458 WEST 57TH STREET HDFC to HOUSING CONSERVATION COORDINATORS, INC.
2025-01-30AL&R $110,000 — from 458 WEST 57 STREET HOUSING DEVELOPMENT F to HOUSING CONSERVATIVE COORDINATORS, INC.$110,000
2025-01-10Permit Sidewalk Shed — Permit Issued
2024
2024-12-10Bedbug filing: 0 infested units
2024-10-03Rodent inspection: Passed
2024-06-27Boiler inspection
2024-01-12Permit Sidewalk Shed — Permit Issued
2023
2023-12-19Bedbug filing: 0 infested units
2023-12-12311: Lead — Lead Kit Request (Residential) (L10)
2023-07-26RPTT&RET $60,251 — from ESTATE OF ROBERT PAUL KALIN; ESTATE OF ROBERT P KALIN; THOMAS KALIN, ADMINISTRATOR to 458 WEST 57 STREET HOUSING DEVELOPMENT F$60,251
2023-07-26RPTT&RET $60,251 — from ESTATE OF ROBERT PAUL KALIN; ESTATE OF ROBERT P KALIN; THOMAS KALIN, ADMINISTRATOR to 458 WEST 57 STREET HOUSING DEVELOPMENT F$60,251
2022-11-25HPD class C: § 27-2031 ADM CODE PROVIDE HOT WATER AT ALL HOT WATER FIXTURES IN THE ENTIRE APARTMENT LOCATED AT APT 2R, 2nd STORY, 1st APARTMENT FROM EAST
2022-11-20311: HEAT/HOT WATER — ENTIRE BUILDING
2022-11-20Tenant complaint: HEAT/HOT WATER — ENTIRE BUILDING
2022-11-02HPD class I: §27-2107 ADM CODE OWNER FAILED TO FILE A VALID REGISTRATION STATEMENT WITH THE DEPARTMENT AS REQUIRED BY ADM CODE §27-2097 AND IS THEREFORE
2022-10-06Permit Sidewalk Shed — Permit Issued
2022-10-05Job filed: PROPOSED INSTALLATION OF HEAVY DUTY SIDEWALK SHED AS PER PLANS. LIVE LOAD 300 PER SQUARE FEET. SIDEWALK SHED SHALL COMPLY WITH CHAPTER # 33 OF THE 20$9,000
2022-10-03311: HEAT/HOT WATER — ENTIRE BUILDING
2022-10-03Tenant complaint: HEAT/HOT WATER — ENTIRE BUILDING
2022-02-16HPD class I: §27-2107 ADM CODE OWNER FAILED TO FILE A VALID REGISTRATION STATEMENT WITH THE DEPARTMENT AS REQUIRED BY ADM CODE §27-2097 AND IS THEREFORE
2022-02-16HPD class A: (A) § HMC:FILE ANNUAL BEDBUG REPORT IN ACCORDANCE WITH HPD RULE AS DESCRIBED ON THE BACK OF THIS NOTICE OF VIOLATION OR AS DESCRIBED ON HPD
2022-01-12Boiler inspection
2021
2021-08-25Rodent inspection: Passed
2021-03-26Boiler inspection
2020
2020-12-22Bedbug filing: 0 infested units
2020-06-25Boiler inspection — defects found
2019
2019-12-09Bedbug filing: 1 infested units
2019-04-23Rodent inspection: Passed
2019-03-11Boiler inspection
2019-03-04311: Request Large Bulky Item Collection — Request Large Bulky Item Collection
2019-01-29Bedbug filing: 7 infested units
2019-01-12311: Request Large Bulky Item Collection — Request Large Bulky Item Collection
2019-01-02RPTT&RET $250 — from BENJAMIN VASQUEZ, ADMINISTRATOR; ESTATE OF ENEIDA VASQUEZ to 458 WEST 57 STREET HOUSING DEVELOPMENT F$250
2019-01-02RPTT&RET $250 — from 458 WEST 57 STREET HOUSING DEVELOPMENT F to VASQUEZ, BENJAMIN; WYNNS, CYNTHIA$250
2019-01-02RPTT&RET $250 — from 458 WEST 57 STREET HOUSING DEVELOPMENT F to COLLIGAN, LORRAINE$250
2018
2018-12-17RPTT&RET $250 — from COLLIGAN, LORRAINE to 458 WEST 57 STREET HOUSING DEVELOPMENT F$250
2018-12-12Sold for $250$250
2018-10-15311: General Construction/Plumbing — Vent/Exhaust - Illegal/Improper
2018-10-15DOB complaint, category ?
2018-06-22Rodent inspection: Passed
2018-05-24311: Noise — Noise: Construction Before/After Hours (NM1)
2018-04-26Boiler inspection
2018-03-14HPD class A: § 329, M/D LAW AND DEPT. RULES AND REGS. PROVIDE A COMPLETED CERTIFICATE OF INSPECTION VISITS IN A PROPER FRAME AT OR NEAR MAILBOXES, BOTTOM
2018-03-14HPD class A: § 27-2013 ADM CODE PAINT WITH LIGHT COLORED PAINT TO THE SATISFACTION OF THIS DEPARTMENT THE NORTH WALL AT PUBLIC HALL STAIRS, 3rd STORY
2018-03-14HPD class B: § 27-2005 ADM CODE PROPERLY REPAIR WITH SIMILAR MATERIAL THE BROKEN OR DEFECTIVE FIRE RETARDANT MATERIAL AT NORTH WALL AT PUBLIC HALL STAIRS
2016-03-15Tenant complaint: HEAT/HOT WATER — ENTIRE BUILDING
2015
2015-10-02HPD class I: SECTION27-2107 ADM CODE OWNER FAILED TO FILE A VALID REGISTRATION STATEMENT WITH THE DEPARTMENT AS REQUIRED BY ADM CODE ?27-2097 AND IS THER
2014
2014-06-03FDNY inspection (RISK)
2013
2013-08-21311: Noise — Noise: air condition/ventilation equipment (NV1)
2010-01-29Job filed: REPLACE METAL BOILER CHIMNEY PER PLANS.$31,500
2010-01-29Job filed: REPLACE METAL BOILER CHIMNEY PER PLANS.$31,500
2010-01-13311: GENERAL CONSTRUCTION — GAS
2010-01-13Tenant complaint: GENERAL — COOKING GAS
2009
2009-10-09Mortgage $50,000 — from 456 WEST 57TH STREET HDFC to HOUSING CONSERVATION COORDINATORS, INC.$50,000
2009-01-26HPD litigation: Heat and Hot Water
2009-01-01DOB violation LL6291:
2008
2008-12-15Tenant complaint: HEATING — HEAT-PLANT
2008-12-15Tenant complaint: HEATING — HEAT RELATED
2008-12-09HPD class B: § 27-2045 ADM CODE REPAIR OR REPLACE THE SMOKE DETECTOR DEFECTIVE IN THE ENTIRE APARTMENT LOCATED AT APT 5R, 5th STORY, 1st APARTMENT FROM E
2008-12-09HPD class B: § 27-2046.1 HMC: REPAIR OR REPLACE THE CARBON MONOXIDE DETECTING DEVICE(S). DEFECTIVE IN THE ENTIRE APARTMENT LOCATED AT APT 5R, 5th STORY,
2008-12-09HPD class C: § 27-2029 ADM CODE DEVICE PRESENT ON CENTRAL HEATING SYSTEM WHICH IS CAPABLE OF CAUSING AN OTHERWISE OPERABLE SYSTEM TO BECOME INOPERABLE TI
2008-12-04Tenant complaint: HEATING — HEAT RELATED
2008-09-18Tenant complaint: PLUMBING — WATER SUPPLY
2008-03-05Tenant complaint: ELECTRIC — ELECTRIC-SUPPLY
2005-10-17Tenant complaint: HEATING — HEAT RELATED
2005-03-01Tenant complaint: HEATING — HEAT RELATED
2005-03-01Tenant complaint: HEATING — HEAT RELATED
2002
2002-03-26DOB violation LL6291:
2001
2001-02-27DOB violation LL6291:
2000
2000-05-29HPD class B: § 27-2040 ADM CODE PROVIDE ADEQUATE LIGHTING AT OR NEAR THE OUTSIDE OF THE FRONT ENTRANCEWAY OF THE BUILDING AND KEEP SAME BURNING FROM SUNS
1999
1999-08-30Permit EW — ISSUED
1999-08-30Permit PL — ISSUED
1999-08-24Permit EW — ISSUED
1997
1997-02-10DOB violation LL6291:
1994
1994-03-18DOB violation LL6291:
1993
1993-03-18DOB violation LL6291:
1991
1991-08-06HPD class B: § 27-2045, 2046 ADM CODE PROVIDE AN APPROVED AND OPERATIONAL SMOKE DETECTING DEVICE, INSTALLED IN ACCORDANCE WITH DEPARTMENT OF BUILDINGS RU
1991-08-06HPD class B: § 27-2005 ADM CODE & 309 M/D LAW ABATE THE NUISANCE CONSISTING OF EXPOSED CEILING BEAMS THROUGHOUT ALL ROOMS 5 STY NORTHWEST APT 5W. , SECTI
1991-07-30HPD class B: § 27-2005, 2007 ADM CODE AND DEPT. RULES AND REGULATIONS. REMOVE THE ENCUMBRANCE OBSTRUCTING EGRESS FROM FIRE ESCAPES FIRE ESCAPES PARTY WAL
1991-07-30HPD class A: D26-10.01 ADM CODE REFIT ENTRANCE DOOR TO 1 STY FRONT EAST APT.
1991-07-30HPD class A: D26-21.03 ADM CODE PAINT OR POST A SIGN INDICATING FLOORS PUBLIC HALL ALL STYS.
1991-07-30HPD class A: § 300 M/D LAW FILE PLANS AND APPLICATION AND LEGALIZE THE FOLLOWING ALTERATION OR RESTORE TO THE LEGAL CONDITION EXISTING PRIOR TO THE MAKIN
1991-07-30HPD class B: D26-10.01 ADM CODE PROPERLY REPAIR WITH SIMILAR MATERIAL THE BROKEN OR DEFECTIVE SOFFIT 3RD TO 4TH STY PUBLIC HALL STAIRS.
1991-07-30HPD class A: § 27-2013 ADM CODE PAINT WITH LIGHT COLORED PAINT TO THE SATISFACTION OF THIS DEPARTMENT CEILING & WALLS AT SOUTHWEST ROOM 5 STY REAR APT 5R
1991-07-30HPD class A: D26-10.01 ADM CODE PROPERLY REPAIR WITH SIMILAR MATERIAL THE BROKEN OR DEFECTIVE TILE FLOOR 1ST STY PUB HALL REAR.
1991-07-30HPD class A: § 27-2013 ADM CODE PAINT WITH LIGHT COLORED PAINT TO THE SATISFACTION OF THIS DEPARTMENT CEILING & WALL ALL STYS PUBLIC HALL.
1991-07-30HPD class A: D26-10.01 ADM CODE PROPERLY REPAIR WITH SIMILAR MATERIAL THE BROKEN OR DEFECTIVE WOOD FLOOR 4TH STY PUBLIC HALL.
1991-07-30HPD class A: D26-10.01 ADM CODE PROVIDE APPROVED FIRE PROOF SELF CLOSING DOOR WITH KEY OPERATED DEADBOLT & LATCH SET PEEPHOLD & CHAIN DOOR GUARD AT ENTRA
1991-07-30HPD class A: D26-10.01 ADM CODE REPAIR THE BROKEN OR DEFECTIVE PLASTERED SURFACES AND PAINT IN A UNIFORM COLOR WALLS AND CEILING 5TH STY REAR APT FRONT W
1991-04-19Mortgage $3,750 — from 458 WEST 57TH ST HDFC to CITY OF NEW YORK$3,750
1991-04-19Deed — from CITY OF NEW YORK to 458 WEST 57TH ST HDFC
1981
1981-09-24HPD class A: D26-10.01 ADM CODE REPAIR THE BROKEN OR DEFECTIVE PLASTERED SURFACES AND PAINT IN A UNIFORM COLOR CEILING 1 STY REAR APT KITCHEN.
1981-08-21HPD class A: § 300 M/D LAW FILE PLANS AND APPLICATION AND LEGALIZE THE FOLLOWING ALTERATION OR RESTORE TO THE LEGAL CONDITION EXISTING PRIOR TO THE MAKIN
1976
1976-04-30Deed — from FINANCE ADMINS CITYNY to CITY OF NEW YORK
1976-03-02HPD class C: D26-10.01 ADM CODE REPAIR THE BROKEN OR DEFECTIVE PLASTERED SURFACES AND PAINT IN A UNIFORM COLOR CEILING 1ST STY FRONT WEST APT 1F KITCHEN
1975
1975-06-17Deed — from LOCAL TEXTILE MILLSINC to ALIC REALTY CORP
1967
1967-05-19Mortgage — from J A J CARPET MART INC to BREE, EILEEN E
1967-05-19Deed — from BREE, EILEEN E to J A J CARPET MART INC
1967-05-19Deed — from J A J CARPET MART INC to LOCAL TEXTILE MILLSINC