A modest record — below the level that usually signals systemic problems. More recorded distress than 82% of 1-5-unit residential buildings citywide. The citywide median for 1-5-unit residential buildings is 0 penalty
points per 10 units; this building carries 10. In ZIP 11216, 38% of residential buildings hold an A and
19% grade D or F.
How grades work
this building
A
C
Among 699,345 1-5-unit residential buildings citywide · left is less recorded distress, right is more
Open with the city right now
No current HPD flags in the latest weekly snapshot: no open violations, no
pending litigation, no active vacate orders, and not in the Alternative Enforcement Program.
Patterns
No heat or hot-water complaints in the last three years.
No bedbug-infested units reported in the last three years of filings.
What 311 hears from this address
2 service requests in the last three years. Most common: Noise (2).
Filed construction activity
$129,750 in permitted construction work filed since
2016 (3 filings with a declared cost) — a rough measure of how actively
the owner maintains the building. Permit costs cover filed construction work only — they do not
capture routine maintenance or repairs done without a permit.
Rent-stabilization signals
Yes
Built before 1974 (1899)
No
Six or more residential units (2)
No
421-a / J-51 tax benefit on the current tax roll
1 of 3 signals present. Only a partial profile — stabilization is possible but less likely. The definitive answer for any unit:
request its rent history from NYS Homes & Community Renewal (free, at hcr.ny.gov).
Registered with HPD — the names behind the building
Registered owner(s)
BROOKLYN HOUSING PRESERVATION LP
Head officer
ILSOO KIM
Managing agent
PROGRESSIVE MANAGEMENT OF NY
Last registered
2025-12-24
as filed by the owner in the building's HPD registration
What the city thinks it's worth
Tax year
City market value
Assessed value
2025
$1,502,000
$90,120
2026
$1,523,000
$91,380
2027
$1,603,000
$96,180
The city's market estimate has risen
7% between tax years 2025 and 2027.
Tax exemptions on the roll: NYC HOUSING AUTH
Flood exposure
Not in the FEMA 1%-annual-chance floodplain (2015 preliminary maps).
Not in a hurricane evacuation zone.
Not in the city's stormwater (cloudburst) flood maps under any modeled scenario.
No street-flooding or sewer-backup complaints on record at this address.
Sources: FEMA flood maps (coastal), NYC DEP Stormwater Flood Maps
(cloudburst), NYC hurricane evacuation zones, and 311 records for this address.
Getting around
Subway
Bedford-Nostrand Avs — G · 900 ft straight-line (about a 4-minute walk) · station accessibility: none
Bus
Nearest boarding stop: Nostrand Av / Greene Av — B44 · 350 ft
Citi Bike
Greene Ave & Nostrand Ave · 450 ft · station location as of 2026-09-23; live availability
Distances are straight-line, not walking routes. Transit locations from the MTA and
Citi Bike, bike facilities from NYC DOT, school zones from the DOE's 2024–25 maps.
2 311 service requests from this address in the last three years.
311 will ask for the address, the apartment if the problem is inside, and what's wrong.
Contact details are optional for most complaints; food-poisoning reports can be anonymous. Complaints
appear in the city's public 311 data, usually within a day or two, and then in the Live from 311 box
on this page.
Most recent mortgage recorded against this lot: $3,706,216 on
2020-02-19 (lender: New York City Housing Development Corporation), covering 98 lots — the amount covers all of them. Face amount at recording — it may have since been paid
down, refinanced or satisfied. View the recorded
document.
Date
Record
Amount
Per res. unit
2020-02-19
Mortgage $4,277,752 — from WILLIAMSBURG PACT HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FU; BROOKLYN HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; WILLIAMSBURG to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR
$4,277,752
2020-02-19
Mortgage $3,944,982 — from WILLIAMSBURG PACT HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FU; BROOKLYN PACT II HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FUN; BROOKL to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR
$3,944,982
2020-02-19
MLEA $10,820,172 — from NEW YORK CITY HOUSING AUTHORITY to BROOKLYN HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; BROOKLYN PACT II HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FUN
$10,820,172
2020-02-19
Mortgage $3,355,087 — from WILLIAMSBURG HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; WILLIAMSBURG PACT HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FU; BROOKLYN to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR
$3,355,087
2020-02-19
Mortgage $3,221,947 — from WILLIAMSBURG PACT HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FU; WILLIAMSBURG HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; BROOKLYN to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR
$3,221,947
2020-02-19
Mortgage $3,094,091 — from WILLIAMSBURG PACT HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FU; BROOKLYN PACT II HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FUN; WILLIA to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR
$3,094,091
2020-02-19
Mortgage $3,788,434 — from WILLIAMSBURG HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; BROOKLYN HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; BROOKLYN PACT to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR
$3,788,434
2020-02-19
Mortgage $3,638,098 — from WILLIAMSBURG PACT HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FU; BROOKLYN PACT II HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FUN; BROOKL to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR
$3,638,098
2020-02-19
Mortgage $1,322,030 — from BROOKLYN PACT II HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FUN; WILLIAMSBURG HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; WILLIAMS to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR
$1,322,030
2020-02-19
Mortgage $3,493,728 — from WILLIAMSBURG HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; WILLIAMSBURG PACT HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FU; BROOKLYN to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR
$3,493,728
2020-02-19
Mortgage $4,454,521 — from WILLIAMSBURG HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; WILLIAMSBURG PACT HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FU; BROOKLYN to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR
$4,454,521
2020-02-19
Mortgage $4,638,593 — from WILLIAMSBURG HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; WILLIAMSBURG PACT HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FU; BROOKLYN to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR
$4,638,593
2020-02-19
Mortgage $2,971,309 — from WILLIAMSBURG HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; WILLIAMSBURG PACT HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FU; BROOKLYN to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR
$2,971,309
2020-02-19
Mortgage $4,830,272 — from WILLIAMSBURG HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; BROOKLYN HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; BROOKLYN PACT to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR
$4,830,272
2020-02-19
Mortgage $5,029,872 — from BROOKLYN PACT II HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FUN; WILLIAMSBURG PACT HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FU; BROOKL to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR
$5,029,872
Ten-year activity
100500
2017
2018
2019
62
2020
2021
2022
2023
2024
2025
2026
ConstructionHousing & tenantsOwnership & moneyHealth & systems
Show as table
Year
Construction
Housing & tenants
Ownership & money
Health & systems
Total
2017
0
0
0
1
1
2018
0
1
0
5
6
2019
1
0
0
4
5
2020
8
1
52
1
62
2021
1
3
0
1
5
2022
0
5
0
2
7
2023
0
1
0
2
3
2024
0
3
0
3
6
2025
0
1
0
2
3
2026
0
1
0
2
3
This record is free. Keeping it free costs money. Servers, data pipelines, weekends. Pay what you want — a dollar helps.
HPD class I: §27-2107 ADM CODE OWNER FAILED TO FILE A VALID REGISTRATION STATEMENT WITH THE DEPARTMENT AS REQUIRED BY ADM CODE §27-2097 AND IS THEREFORE
The full timeline
2026
2026-09-10Rodent inspection: Passed
2026-05-21Bedbug filing: 0 infested units
2026-03-09Rodent inspection: Passed
2025
2025-11-24HPD class I: §27-2107 ADM CODE OWNER FAILED TO FILE A VALID REGISTRATION STATEMENT WITH THE DEPARTMENT AS REQUIRED BY ADM CODE §27-2097 AND IS THEREFORE
2021-04-21HPD class I: §27-2107 ADM CODE OWNER FAILED TO FILE A VALID REGISTRATION STATEMENT WITH THE DEPARTMENT AS REQUIRED BY ADM CODE §27-2097 AND IS THEREFORE
2020-06-12Job filed: RENOVATIONS TO THE EXISTING FACADE. NO CHANGE IN EGRESS USE OR OCCUPANCY.$6,750
2020-05-18Job filed: INSTALL NEW ROOF MEMBRANE OVER EXISTING ROOF ASSEMBLY, REPAIR OR REPLACE ALL BASE FLASHING AS REQUIRED AND INSTALL NEW ROOF INSULATION. NO CHANCE IN E$8,000
2020-03-06Rodent inspection: Passed
2020-02-19Mortgage $4,277,752 — from WILLIAMSBURG PACT HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FU; BROOKLYN HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; WILLIAMSBURG to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$4,277,752
2020-02-19Mortgage $3,944,982 — from WILLIAMSBURG PACT HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FU; BROOKLYN PACT II HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FUN; BROOKL to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$3,944,982
2020-02-19Agreement — from NEW YORK CITY HOUSING AUTHORITY to BROOKLYN PACT HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FUND C; BROOKLYN HOUSING PRESERVATION, L.P.
2020-02-19MLEA $10,820,172 — from NEW YORK CITY HOUSING AUTHORITY to BROOKLYN HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; BROOKLYN PACT II HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FUN$10,820,172
2020-02-19SAGE — from BROOKLYN HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P. to BROOKLYN PACT II HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FUN
2020-02-19Mortgage $3,355,087 — from WILLIAMSBURG HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; WILLIAMSBURG PACT HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FU; BROOKLYN to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$3,355,087
2020-02-19Mortgage $3,221,947 — from WILLIAMSBURG PACT HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FU; WILLIAMSBURG HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; BROOKLYN to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$3,221,947
2020-02-19Mortgage $3,094,091 — from WILLIAMSBURG PACT HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FU; BROOKLYN PACT II HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FUN; WILLIA to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$3,094,091
2020-02-19Mortgage $3,788,434 — from WILLIAMSBURG HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; BROOKLYN HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; BROOKLYN PACT to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$3,788,434
2020-02-19Mortgage $3,638,098 — from WILLIAMSBURG PACT HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FU; BROOKLYN PACT II HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FUN; BROOKL to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$3,638,098
2020-02-19Mortgage $1,322,030 — from BROOKLYN PACT II HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FUN; WILLIAMSBURG HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; WILLIAMS to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$1,322,030
2020-02-19Mortgage $3,493,728 — from WILLIAMSBURG HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; WILLIAMSBURG PACT HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FU; BROOKLYN to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$3,493,728
2020-02-19Mortgage $4,454,521 — from WILLIAMSBURG HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; WILLIAMSBURG PACT HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FU; BROOKLYN to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$4,454,521
2020-02-19Mortgage $4,638,593 — from WILLIAMSBURG HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; WILLIAMSBURG PACT HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FU; BROOKLYN to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$4,638,593
2020-02-19Mortgage $2,971,309 — from WILLIAMSBURG HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; WILLIAMSBURG PACT HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FU; BROOKLYN to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$2,971,309
2020-02-19Mortgage $4,830,272 — from WILLIAMSBURG HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; BROOKLYN HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; BROOKLYN PACT to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$4,830,272
2020-02-19Mortgage $5,029,872 — from BROOKLYN PACT II HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FUN; WILLIAMSBURG PACT HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FU; BROOKL to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$5,029,872
2020-02-19Mortgage $5,237,720 — from BROOKLYN HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; WILLIAMSBURG HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; WILLIAMSBURG P to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$5,237,720
2020-02-19Mortgage $5,454,156 — from WILLIAMSBURG HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; BROOKLYN PACT II HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FUN; WILLIAMS to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$5,454,156
2020-02-19Mortgage $5,679,536 — from WILLIAMSBURG HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; BROOKLYN HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; BROOKLYN PACT to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$5,679,536
2020-02-19Mortgage $4,702,897 — from BROOKLYN PACT II HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FUN; WILLIAMSBURG HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; BROOKLYN to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$4,702,897
2020-02-19Mortgage $2,853,399 — from WILLIAMSBURG HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; WILLIAMSBURG PACT HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FU; BROOKLYN to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$2,853,399
2020-02-19REL — from UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING AND to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING AUTHORITY
2020-02-19Mortgage $4,897,233 — from WILLIAMSBURG PACT HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FU; BROOKLYN HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; BROOKLYN PAC to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$4,897,233
2020-02-19Mortgage $337,500,000 — from WILLIAMSBURG PACT HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FU; WILLIAMSBURG HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; BROOKLYN to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$337,500,000
2020-02-19Mortgage $2,740,168 — from WILLIAMSBURG PACT HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FU; BROOKLYN HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; WILLIAMSBURG to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$2,740,168
2020-02-19Mortgage $337,500,000 — from BROOKLYN HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; WILLIAMSBURG PACT HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FU; WILLIAMSBURG to FEDERAL HOME LOAN MORTGAGE CORPORATION$337,500,000
2020-02-19Mortgage $2,631,430 — from WILLIAMSBURG HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; WILLIAMSBURG PACT HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FU; BROOKLYN to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$2,631,430
2020-02-19Mortgage $2,527,007 — from BROOKLYN HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; BROOKLYN PACT II HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FUN; WILLIAMSBURG to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$2,527,007
2020-02-19Mortgage $2,426,728 — from WILLIAMSBURG PACT HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FU; BROOKLYN PACT II HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FUN; WILLIA to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$2,426,728
2020-02-19Mortgage $2,330,429 — from WILLIAMSBURG PACT HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FU; BROOKLYN PACT II HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FUN; BROOKL to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$2,330,429
2020-02-19SAGE — from NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR to FEDERAL HOME LOAN MORTGAGE CORPORATION
2020-02-19Mortgage $33,793,784 — from BROOKLYN HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; BROOKLYN PACT II HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FUN; WILLIAMSBURG to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$33,793,784
2020-02-19Mortgage $3,706,216 — from WILLIAMSBURG PACT HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FU; BROOKLYN HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; WILLIAMSBURG to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$3,706,216
2020-02-19SAGE — from FEDERAL HOME LOAN MORTGAGE CORPORATION to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR
2020-02-19Mortgage $2,063,858 — from WILLIAMSBURG PACT HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FU; BROOKLYN PACT II HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FUN; BROOKL to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$2,063,858
2020-02-19Mortgage $1,981,959 — from WILLIAMSBURG HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; BROOKLYN PACT II HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FUN; BROOKLYN to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$1,981,959
2020-02-19Mortgage $1,903,309 — from WILLIAMSBURG PACT HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FU; BROOKLYN HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; BROOKLYN PAC to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$1,903,309
2020-02-19Mortgage $1,827,780 — from BROOKLYN PACT II HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FUN; WILLIAMSBURG HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; BROOKLYN to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$1,827,780
2020-02-19Mortgage $1,755,249 — from WILLIAMSBURG PACT HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FU; BROOKLYN HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; BROOKLYN PAC to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$1,755,249
2020-02-19Mortgage $1,685,595 — from WILLIAMSBURG HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; BROOKLYN HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; WILLIAMSBURG P to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$1,685,595
2020-02-19Mortgage $1,269,569 — from WILLIAMSBURG PACT HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FU; BROOKLYN PACT II HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FUN; BROOKL to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$1,269,569
2020-02-19Mortgage $1,618,706 — from WILLIAMSBURG PACT HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FU; WILLIAMSBURG HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; BROOKLYN to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$1,618,706
2020-02-19Mortgage $1,554,471 — from WILLIAMSBURG HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; BROOKLYN HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; BROOKLYN PACT to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$1,554,471
2020-02-19Mortgage $1,492,785 — from BROOKLYN PACT II HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FUN; WILLIAMSBURG PACT HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FU; BROOKL to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$1,492,785
2020-02-19Agreement — from BROOKLYN PACT II HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FUN; WILLIAMSBURG HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; BROOKLYN to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR
2020-02-19Mortgage $2,237,951 — from WILLIAMSBURG PACT HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FU; BROOKLYN HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; WILLIAMSBURG to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$2,237,951
2020-02-19SAGE — from NEW YORK CITY HOUSING AUTHORITY to BROOKLYN PACT II HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FUN; BROOKLYN HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; U.S. DEPARTM
2020-02-19Mortgage $1,433,547 — from WILLIAMSBURG PACT HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FU; WILLIAMSBURG HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; BROOKLYN to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$1,433,547
2020-02-19Mortgage $4,107,999 — from BROOKLYN PACT II HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FUN; BROOKLYN HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; WILLIAMSBURG to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$4,107,999
2020-02-19Mortgage $1,376,660 — from BROOKLYN HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; WILLIAMSBURG PACT HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FU; BROOKLYN PAC to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$1,376,660
2020-02-19Mortgage $2,149,143 — from BROOKLYN PACT II HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FUN; WILLIAMSBURG HOUSING PRESERVATION L.P.; WILLIAMS to NEW YORK CITY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPOR$2,149,143
2020-01-02Permit EW — ISSUED
2019
2019-11-19Job filed: INTERIOR RENOVATION INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO REPLACEMENT OF KITCHEN CABINETS, APPLIANCES, EXISTING WINDOWS, KITCHEN AND BATHROOM FIXTURES, LIGHTIN$115,000
2019-10-10Rodent inspection: Passed
2019-09-04Rodent inspection: Passed
2019-06-15Rodent inspection: Passed
2019-03-28Rodent inspection: Passed
2018
2018-11-09311: Damaged Tree — Tree Leaning/Uprooted
2018-09-24Rodent inspection: Passed
2018-09-24Rodent inspection: Passed
2018-04-15Rodent inspection: Failed for Other Reason